Legal
Latest
- Legal
Holland & Hart Urges Rural Hospitals to Document RHTP Fund Use
In a client alert, Holland & Hart LLP notes CMS has announced second-year Rural Health Transformation Program awards, with Montana receiving $239.7 million, the third-largest award nationally, and Idaho receiving $182.7 million. The firm explains that critical access hospitals accepting subawards face federal reporting and documentation obligations that flow down through the state, with Year 1 quarterly reports due November 30, and that HHS-OIG retains authority to review how funds are used even though states administer the subawards. The firm advises hospitals to maintain evidence at each CMS checkpoint, from planning through sustainability, because CMS uses annual reporting to inform future funding, and warns that inaccurate certified reports can create False Claims Act exposure in addition to disallowed costs.
- Legal · PA
Jefferson Health Sues Highmark Over Specialty Pharmacy Access
Lehigh Valley Health Network's specialty pharmacy, operated under Jefferson Health, filed suit against Highmark on Nov. 10 in state court, alleging the insurer is blocking its pharmacy from dispensing certain high-cost, self-administered specialty drugs to Highmark members. The complaint claims that despite a September 2023 contract naming LVHN's pharmacy as a participating provider, Highmark created a "closed specialty" drug list around summer 2024 that routes prescriptions to other pharmacies, including Highmark-owned Allegheny Health Network Specialty Pharmacy, before informing LVHN in July 2025. LVHN argues its tier designation can only be changed through a contract amendment and is asking the court to order Highmark to eliminate the closed list, citing millions of dollars in damages. Highmark says it stands behind its specialty drug management program and is reviewing the claims; Jefferson is separately in contract negotiations with Highmark ahead of 2027 and has also sued Independence Blue Cross and Aetna this year.
- Legal · RI
Neighborhood Health Plan Sues Rhode Island Over $100M in Unpaid Claims
Neighborhood Health Plan of Rhode Island, the state's largest Medicaid managed care organization, filed suit against the Rhode Island Executive Office of Health and Human Services and interim director Kristen Sousa, alleging $100 million in overdue Medicaid reimbursements dating back more than a decade. The complaint, filed Oct. 30 in Providence County Superior Court, claims the state failed to recalculate and reimburse higher costs tied to covering medically needy members, particularly those in long-term care and nursing facilities, under contracts spanning 2013 to 2025. Neighborhood attributes the underpayments to the botched rollout of the state's RIBridges (formerly UHIP) benefits system, which created years-long backlogs in processing and reconciling eligibility data. The insurer is asking a judge to order repayment plus damages, or to appoint a special master or independent auditor to determine amounts owed.

- Legal · NY
NY AG settles with Carelon over behavioral health 'ghost networks'
New York Attorney General Letitia James' office announced Nov. 10 that Carelon Behavioral Health will pay $2.35 million in penalties, fees and costs and up to $8 million in restitution under two settlements. The settlements resolve investigations into mental health "ghost networks" and improper denials of substance use disorder treatment. Restitution covers members who paid out of pocket for out-of-network mental healthcare after being unable to get an in-network appointment, members overcharged due to inaccurate provider listings, and members denied addiction treatment using criteria not approved by the state. Carelon administers behavioral health benefits for more than 4 million New Yorkers, with clients including EmblemHealth, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Independent Health and the Empire Plan, which covers state and local government employees. Under the settlements, Carelon must correct directory errors within two business days, verify provider data every 90 days, run quarterly secret shopper surveys, and meet appointment-timeliness standards, with an independent monitor reporting to the attorney general's office every six months.
- Legal
Oberheiden PC Outlines Provider Response Strategy for CMS Audit Notices
In a law firm client alert, Oberheiden PC attorneys explain how healthcare providers should respond to audit notices from CMS contractors covering Medicare and Medicaid billing. The piece describes several CMS contractor audit types, including CERT, MAC, RAC, UPIC, SMRC, and TPE audits, along with HHS OIG audits, and notes each carries distinct risks such as recoupments, payment suspensions, and criminal referrals. It states that even providers who fully complied with billing rules can face liability if they cannot affirmatively document that compliance, and that audits are often already underway by the time a provider receives notice.
- Legal · OK
Oklahoma Supreme Court Strikes Down Initiative Petition Restriction Law
The Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that Senate Bill 1027, a 2025 law restricting the state's initiative petition process, violates the U.S. and Oklahoma Constitutions and is void and unenforceable in its entirety. The law had capped signature collection by county, restricted paid circulators, banned incentive-based compensation, required circulators to be registered Oklahoma voters, and limited petition wording, measures the court found created First Amendment and voter disenfranchisement problems. House Speaker Kyle Hilbert and Sen. David Bullard authored the law and Hilbert is urging the state to appeal. The court noted that citizens had previously used the initiative petition process to expand Medicaid, legalize medical marijuana, and enact criminal justice reform, issues lawmakers had declined to pursue.

- Legal
Democratic Lawmakers Demand Drugmakers Disclose MFN Deal Details
Congressional Democrats, including Reps. Frank Pallone Jr., Richard Neal, Bobby Scott and Sen. Ron Wyden, are demanding pharmaceutical companies disclose un-redacted details of their "most favored nation" drug pricing agreements with the Trump administration, according to a source familiar with the effort. If companies cannot provide the details, for example due to potential non-disclosure agreements with the White House, they were told to meet with lawmakers within two weeks to discuss how they will fulfill the request. The same four lawmakers sent a similar letter in March that the administration did not answer. Lawmakers want to know what drug companies are receiving in exchange for agreeing to lower prices for Medicaid, and to verify administration claims about savings to the public.
- Legal · NV
Opinion: Nevada Fails to Shield Gender-Affirming Care Providers
In a Nevada opinion piece, the author argues that despite Nevada's 2023 law (SB163) requiring certain insurance, including Medicaid, to cover gender-affirming care for gender dysphoria, the state has failed to protect providers who offer it. The author cites Gov. Joe Lombardo's vetoes of SB302 and SB171, bills that would have barred medical licensing boards from disciplining providers of gender-affirming care and blocked extradition over out-of-state charges, while the state passed shield laws for reproductive rights in the same period. The piece quotes Dr. Michael Uzmann, a Las Vegas endocrinologist, saying providers need policy protections against out-of-state subpoenas, records requests, investigations or extradition tied to legally provided care, and reports he received roughly 300 new transgender patients after Huntridge Family Clinic's temporary closure. The author argues this leaves trans Nevadans, including Medicaid enrollees, without reliable access to the care the state's insurance mandate is supposed to guarantee.
- Legal · IN
OIG Finds County Hospitals Kept $205M Meant for Indiana Nursing Homes
An OIG audit released Tuesday found that $205.2 million in Medicaid supplemental payments intended to boost reimbursement for Indiana nursing facilities was instead recouped by county hospitals, which operate about 97% of nursing facilities in the state. OIG reported that nearly half of Indiana's supplemental payments, $479.8 million total, were recovered by nonstate government-owned entities like county hospitals, including $274.6 million in state-share funds those entities had initially contributed. Indiana received the highest nursing facility supplemental payments nationally in fiscal 2022, about $1.02 billion of $2.36 billion reported nationwide, prompting OIG's audit. The audit also found $12.2 million in federal payments that did not comply with federal and state requirements, due to unreported overpayments, a leap-year calculation error, and an incorrect federal matching rate; OIG recommended Indiana refund that amount and explore ways to increase the share of payments retained by participating nursing facilities.

- Legal
OIG Approves Provider-Backed Subsidies for Special Needs Trust Fees
In OIG Advisory Opinion 26-19, the Office of Inspector General approved an arrangement allowing certain health care providers to subsidize costs that Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries incur to maintain their eligibility for those programs, specifically fees associated with pooled special needs trusts. The opinion, discussed in a Krieg DeVault analysis, reflects OIG's continued support for donor-funded patient assistance programs when structured with appropriate safeguards. Beneficiaries who rely on pooled special needs trusts to preserve Medicaid and Medicare eligibility are affected by the arrangement.
- Legal · PA
Redeemer Health to Sell or Close Pennsylvania Hospital Amid Bankruptcy
Redeemer Health's board plans to sell or close Holy Redeemer Hospital after the system and 11 affiliates filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy Nov. 1, according to a declaration filed with the petitions in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. CEO James Logue said continued operation of the 239-bed hospital is not sustainable; the hospital and its physician network lost between $31.6 million and $48.9 million annually over the past five years. Redeemer reported about $441 million in total liabilities as of April 30, 2026, and about $8.39 million in unpaid employee wages across roughly 2,770 employees, with court approval for about $700,000 on Nov. 4 to pay 29 "key" employees. The bankruptcy court held a hearing Nov. 4 on Redeemer's request to use cash collateral, and the judge entered an interim order Nov. 9 allowing it, with a final hearing scheduled for Dec. 14; the system plans to keep and invest in its older adult and life care operations, which did not file for bankruptcy.
- Legal · TN
Patient Sues Ascension St. Thomas for $150M Over Pharmacy Error
A 78-year-old patient, Linda Gilbert, has sued Nashville-based Ascension St. Thomas Midtown for $150 million after an August pharmacy error left her paraplegic, according to a Nov. 9 WTVF report. The suit alleges a pharmacy technician mixed up potassium phosphate with an anesthetic during joint replacement surgery, one of four patients affected that day, and that staff proceeded with surgery despite her reported leg pain rather than investigating. The complaint cites state regulators' findings of look-alike drug storage and staff ability to override barcode scanning, and challenges Tennessee's damages cap as unconstitutional. The Tennessee Health Facilities Commission had cited the hospital for immediate jeopardy, CMS lifted that designation after a revisit but the risk of Medicare funding termination remains through June 2027, and the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has opened an inquiry with no charges filed.
- Legal
NHeLP Argues OBBBA Will Inflate Medicaid Erroneous Payment Rates
In a National Health Law Program blog, the second in a series on OBBBA's changes to Medicaid's Payment Error Rate Measurement, NHeLP argues that OBBBA expands the statutory definition of "erroneous payments" to include payments lacking sufficient documentation, a category traditionally classified as "improper payments." NHeLP states this definitional change will artificially inflate erroneous payment rates by conflating administrative processing issues with fraudulent activity, even if the actual amount of erroneous payments as previously defined has not changed. The piece notes that during the most recent PERM cycle most states had no erroneous payments, and those that did generally had rates below 1 percent, and that between fiscal years 2021 and 2025 only 4 percent of payment errors involved confirmed ineligible people. NHeLP contends the changes will also expand states' financial liability and leave states with fewer resources while fueling claims of widespread Medicaid fraud.
- Legal
Biotech Groups Sue CMS Over GLOBE Drug Pricing Model
Three biotechnology trade groups, the Biotechnology Innovation Organization, Biocom and California Life Sciences, filed a lawsuit Nov. 6 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California challenging CMS's Global Benchmark for Efficient Drug Pricing Model, or GLOBE. The groups argue CMS exceeded its statutory authority, violated federal appropriations law, and breached separation-of-powers principles, contending the agency's testing authority is limited to models addressing a defined population with care deficits. Under GLOBE, manufacturers of certain Medicare Part B drugs would pay rebates based on the gap between U.S. prices and government-controlled prices in 19 foreign countries. The groups, representing over a third of U.S. biotech companies, cited a January 2026 analysis finding only 0.3% of Medicare Part B beneficiaries would have seen lower out-of-pocket costs, and warned the model could restrict patient access and discourage drug development.
- Legal
States Reach $10M Settlement With Health IT Vendor Over Data Breach
New York Attorney General Letitia James announced a settlement of up to $10 million on Nov. 6 with health IT vendor Perry Johnson & Associates and four affiliated companies, resolving claims from attorneys general in New York, Connecticut, Michigan and New Jersey over a 2023 data breach that exposed information on more than 13.3 million people. Hackers accessed the company's systems in March 2023 using an employee's credentials; the company lacked multifactor authentication and did not discover the breach until contacted by the attackers two months later. Compromised data included names, Social Security numbers, diagnoses, insurance information and clinical test results. Affected health systems included Cook County Health and Northwell Health. The settlement requires at least $300,000 in penalties and costs, with an additional $9.7 million owed if the companies fail to comply with required cybersecurity reforms including multifactor authentication, encryption and annual HIPAA-consistent risk assessments.
- Legal · MN
Commentary: Writer Urges Prosecution of Federal Agents, Medicaid Restoration
In a Minnesota Reformer commentary, the author argues that Minnesota's newly elected Democratic leaders should pursue "justice and accountability" against federal agents involved in the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti, and should reverse Trump administration policies. The author cites a Democratic "100-day agenda," including ending cuts to Medicaid and ACA subsidies that the piece says ended coverage for disabled people and raised premiums for millions of families. The commentary also references a DFL push for gun safety legislation and praises Gov. Tim Walz's visit to memorials for the two people killed. No legislative or legal action is reported as having occurred; the piece is an opinion argument following the midterm election.

- Legal · WA
Washington Wins $900M Verdict Against Albertsons Over Opioid Dispensing
A King County Superior Court judge ordered Albertsons to pay Washington state $900 million plus fees and costs, ruling its pharmacies failed to prevent opioid misuse and diversion. Judge Janet Helson issued the ruling Nov. 5 following a nine-week nonjury trial in a case the state filed in 2022. The attorney general's office said Albertsons dispensed more than 641 million opioid pills in the state from 2006 to 2022, most with unresolved "red flags of diversion," and filled red-flagged prescriptions more than 6.5 million times without documenting legitimacy checks. The judge awarded $800 million for abatement and $100 million in penalties, which would rise to about $340 million if the abatement order is overturned on appeal; Albertsons said it is disappointed and considering an appeal.
- Legal · IA
Iowa Board Warns Nurse After Nursing Home Resident's Death
Iowa licensing officials issued a warning and ordered 30 hours of educational training for licensed practical nurse Elaine Allison, also known as Elaine McCoy, after a resident at Oskaloosa Care Center died in September 2025. The board alleges Allison failed to call an ambulance and incorrectly identified the resident as "no code" when he was actually a "full code" patient who had requested lifesaving measures; as a result no CPR was performed before he was pronounced dead. State inspectors found the resident's door lacked the correct code-status sticker due to recent room reassignments and that staff could not locate the facility's crash cart during the emergency. The state proposed a suspended $10,000 fine against the facility, and the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services separately fined the home $45,354.

- Legal · WI
Milwaukee Woman Charged in Alleged $1 Million Medicaid Fraud Scheme
The Wisconsin Department of Justice announced charges against a Milwaukee woman accused of defrauding Wisconsin Medicaid of more than $1 million through an alleged fraud scheme. The press release naming the charges was published November 5, 2026. No further details on the scheme's mechanics, the defendant's identity, or case status were provided in the listed item.
- Legal · TX
Justice Department Moves to Join Texas Suit Against Planned Parenthood
The U.S. Justice Department notified a federal court it will intervene in a lawsuit Texas joined in 2022 against Planned Parenthood over alleged improper Medicaid billing, according to the Texas Tribune. The intervention comes days after Democrat Nathan Johnson was elected Texas attorney general, succeeding outgoing Republican Ken Paxton, who championed the case and recently lost a U.S. Senate bid. Texas is seeking more than $1.8 billion in reimbursement, penalties and fees over roughly $10 million in Medicaid payments Planned Parenthood received while the state sought to remove it from the Medicaid program. Planned Parenthood calls the suit "meritless" and says it will keep fighting; the case is set for an April 2027 trial before U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk. Johnson has not said how he will handle the case once in office.