Legal
Latest
- Legal
Appeals Court Weighs DOJ Bid to Reinstate Kennedy's Vaccine Panel Picks
The Trump administration argued before the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that a district court judge lacked authority to block Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s appointees from serving on a key federal vaccine advisory panel. Justice Department attorney Matthew Zorn contended the lower court erred in its ruling. The appeals panel has not yet issued a decision on whether the injunction blocking the appointments will stand. The case centers on control over vaccine policy recommendations that influence immunization schedules nationally.

- Legal
OIG FAQ Update Warns Stark Compliance Won't Shield AKS Liability
In a client alert, law firm Hall Render reports that OIG revised its General Questions Regarding Certain Fraud and Abuse Authorities to clarify that satisfying a Stark Law exception does not automatically protect an arrangement from Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) liability, and that fair market value compensation alone does not preclude AKS risk. The guidance affects hospitals, physician groups, labs and other providers negotiating or reviewing financial arrangements with referral sources, since OIG emphasized that intent and surrounding facts and circumstances remain central to AKS analysis even when Stark exceptions or FMV benchmarks are met. OIG illustrated the point using an example involving entertainment tickets offered to physician referral sources. Hall Render recommends providers conduct separate Stark and AKS analyses, confirm every element of applicable safe harbors, and document the legitimate business purpose behind compensation arrangements.
- Legal · WV
Commentary: WV Hospitals Overstate Charity Care, Undercount Bad Debt
In a commentary piece, the author argues that West Virginia's non-profit hospitals are failing to deliver on the charity care obligations tied to their tax-exempt status as federal Medicaid changes under H.R. 1 threaten to cut enrollment by up to 75,000 people. The author cites West Virginia Hospital Association data showing charity care averages just 0.9% of net patient revenue, with hospitals writing off more in bad debt ($103 million) than they forgave in charity care ($79 million), while inflating "community benefit" totals by including provider tax payments and Medicare shortfalls excluded under Catholic Health Association standards. The piece points to Texas and Oregon as models that condition tax exemption on meeting charity care standards or require financial screening before collections. The author urges West Virginia's upcoming legislative session to mandate true charity care and pre-collection financial screening.

- Legal
DOJ Retreats From Enforcing Olmstead Disability Integration Rights
The Trump administration's Department of Justice has moved to stop enforcing Olmstead v. L.C., the 1999 Supreme Court ruling requiring states to serve people with disabilities in the most integrated setting rather than institutions. A June DOJ memo stated the federal government has no obligation to enforce Olmstead, and in August the department began withdrawing from cases defending disabled people seeking home- and community-based care. Last month DOJ settled Texas v. Kennedy, invalidating federal regulations that defined what it means to live in a community. Disability advocates warn the shift threatens decades of progress moving people out of institutions and into home and community-based Medicaid-funded care.

- Legal
Oracle Health Discloses 2025 Breach Affected Nearly 20 Million
Bloomberg reports, citing a Texas attorney general disclosure, that Oracle Health's 2025 data breach compromised personal information of nearly 20 million people nationwide, including almost 3 million Texans. The breach involved older Cerner servers accessed by attackers sometime after January 22, 2025, before that data had been migrated to Oracle's cloud. Exposed information varied by patient but could include names, addresses, Social Security numbers, physicians, diagnoses, medications and test results. Oracle's healthcare customers include hospitals, clinics, the Defense Department and VA, though the VA said it was not affected; at least 29 hospitals and health systems have reported impact, and Oracle Health faces litigation over the incident.
- Legal
FTC Warns 24 Hospital Systems Over Price Transparency Failures
The FTC sent warning letters to two dozen hospital systems, alleging that incomplete or misleading price disclosures may violate federal consumer protection laws. The letters target hospitals' compliance with price transparency rules requiring public posting of standard charges and shoppable service prices. No specific compliance deadline or enforcement action was announced, but the letters signal heightened federal scrutiny of hospital pricing practices. The action matters for hospitals and health systems serving Medicaid and dual-eligible populations, where pricing transparency intersects with billing practices and consumer protection obligations.

- Legal
DOJ Revises Justice Manual on FCA Guidance and Dismissal Policy
In a client alert, Hall Render reports that the Department of Justice has revised its Justice Manual to reshape False Claims Act enforcement in two ways. First, the revision confirms that sub-regulatory guidance, such as CMS manuals, coverage policies, and local coverage determinations, cannot alone establish FCA liability; an enforcement action must rest on an actual violation of a statute, regulation, or other binding legal requirement, though such guidance can still show notice or scienter. Second, DOJ attorneys must now affirmatively consider seeking dismissal of declined qui tam actions, including meritless, parasitic, or resource-draining claims, and may revisit dismissal later in litigation. Health care providers facing FCA claims tied to agency guidance are most directly affected by these changes.
- Legal
FTC Warns 24 Hospital Systems Over Deceptive Pricing Practices
FTC Chair Andrew Ferguson sent letters on Oct. 5 to 24 of the nation's largest health systems, warning that incomplete, inaccurate, or untimely price disclosures could violate Section 5 of the FTC Act even if hospitals comply with CMS price transparency rules. The agency said CMS requirements set a baseline but offer no safe harbor from consumer protection liability, and that omitting physician or facility fees from price estimates could be deemed deceptive. The FTC also flagged as potentially unfair any failure to give patients complete pricing information far enough in advance to compare providers, particularly for scheduled nonemergency services. The agency did not name the health systems but said it will continue monitoring pricing practices and pursue enforcement as warranted.
- Legal · TX
Texas AG Paxton Launches Investigation Into UnitedHealth Over Care Denials
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton announced an investigation into UnitedHealth Group on Oct. 5, citing allegations of "deceptive and unlawful practices" that may have denied Texans medically necessary care. The announcement references reports that the company bribed nursing homes to delay hospitalizing patients who needed care, and raises concerns that coverage determinations overrode physicians' medical judgment. Paxton's office issued Civil Investigative Demands to UnitedHealth to assess compliance with state law. This follows a similar investigation Paxton's office opened in late September into Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas and its parent, Health Care Service Corp., over care denials, delays, and prior authorization concerns.
- Legal · FL
Uthmeier Defends Hope Florida Medicaid Settlement Fund Transfers
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier again defended as "entirely legal" the diversion of $10 million from a Medicaid overbilling settlement with Centene through the Hope Florida Foundation, despite a state grand jury finding the DeSantis administration "misappropriated" the funds in a "sophisticated scheme to fund political activities." The grand jury found the money passed through several nonprofits to a political committee that opposed a 2024 marijuana legalization ballot initiative, though no indictments were issued due to insufficient evidence. Uthmeier, who was DeSantis' chief of staff during the transfer and is now running for attorney general, compared the arrangement to Triumph Florida, a legislatively created entity handling BP oil spill settlement funds. His Democratic opponent, José Javier Rodríguez, called for the $10 million to be returned to the Medicaid program.

- Legal
House GOP Releases Fraud Report, Unveils 13 Medicaid Bills
In a commentary piece, the author argues that the House Energy & Commerce Committee's Republican majority staff report on Medicare and Medicaid fraud, released September 29, is politically timed oversight published five weeks before the midterm elections. The same day, the Committee Chairman announced a package of 14 bills, 13 of which would amend the Medicaid statute to address program fraud. The piece characterizes the report and legislative package as "oversight done wrong," suggesting the timing and substance warrant scrutiny. The author's framing questions whether the report's findings and proposed legislative fixes are driven by genuine oversight concerns or electoral strategy.
- Legal · SC
Stomagienics CEO Criticizes Medicare Ostomy Supply Bidding Plan
In a commentary published ahead of Ostomy Awareness Day, Theresa Johnson, CEO of South Carolina-based Stomagienics, argues that CMS's plan to apply competitive bidding to ostomy supplies will harm patients. She writes that beginning January 1, 2028, CMS will award contracts to just six suppliers nationwide, which she argues will reduce access to the specific, properly-fitting products beneficiaries need, since ostomy products are not interchangeable commodities. Johnson cites United Ostomy Associations of America estimates that 13,200 South Carolinians live with an ostomy, including 8,580 Medicare beneficiaries, and warns that a dozen South Carolina supply companies could be forced to reduce or eliminate ostomy offerings. She contends that lowering product costs through bidding risks raising overall care costs through leakage, skin damage, infections, and hospitalizations, and urges Congress to weigh real-world patient outcomes rather than price alone.

- Legal
Eleventh Circuit Upholds False Claims Act's Qui Tam Provisions
The Eleventh Circuit reversed a district court ruling and held that False Claims Act whistleblowers (relators) are not "Officers of the United States" subject to the Constitution's Appointments Clause, in United States ex rel. Zafirov v. Florida Medical Associates. The court reasoned relators do not occupy a continuing government position, they lack a permanent office, government salary, or ongoing duties, and their recovery is a contingent, case-specific bounty rather than compensation for institutional service. The case, which originated as a Medicare fraud action, was remanded to the district court to address separate Take Care Clause and Vesting Clause challenges. The ruling preserves qui tam enforcement authority within the Eleventh Circuit, though other constitutional challenges to the FCA framework remain pending on remand and in other circuits.
- Legal
DOJ Creates Fraud Division Targeting Medicare, Medicaid Fraud
In a client alert, Hall Render reports that the DOJ has issued a memorandum announcing priorities for its newly created National Fraud Enforcement Division, naming health care fraud as a top focus. The Division will prioritize telemedicine arrangements, Medicare and Medicaid fraud, controlled-substance diversion, home health and hospice programs, and marketing of unsafe or misrepresented health products. DOJ plans a more coordinated, data-driven enforcement approach, including use of large language models and AI tools to analyze unstructured records like EHR documentation, contracts, and compliance materials alongside claims and billing data. Hall Render advises providers to review compliance programs, coding/billing practices, and federal health care program submissions to reduce enforcement risk.
- Legal · CA
California Doctors, Health Plans Sue Newsom Over MCO Tax Hike
The California Medical Association and California Association of Health Plans filed suit Friday with the California Supreme Court against Gov. Gavin Newsom and the Legislature, alleging a June managed care organization (MCO) tax increase on private health plans violates Proposition 35, a 2024 voter initiative limiting healthcare taxes and dedicating revenue to Medi-Cal. The groups say the tax hike, prompted by federal changes to allowable healthcare tax structures, will raise individual premiums by about $100 annually ($400 for a family of four) as insurers pass costs to consumers. The state structured two competing tax versions for federal approval, one compliant with Prop 35 but likely to be rejected federally, and one that meets federal rules but largely bypasses the initiative, to preserve the revenue stream amid federal Medicaid funding cuts. No effective date or ruling timeline was given; the case is pending before the state Supreme Court.

- Legal
Independence Blue Cross Pays $22.5M to Settle MA Fraud Claims
Independence Blue Cross agreed to pay $22.5 million to resolve allegations that it inflated diagnosis codes for Medicare Advantage beneficiaries to boost risk-adjustment payments. The insurer described the settlement, along with similar resolutions by other payers, as reflecting "industry-wide challenges" in applying Medicare Advantage risk adjustment standards. The matter concerns Medicare Advantage rather than Medicaid managed care directly, though risk adjustment practices and enforcement scrutiny often extend across both program types for payers operating in both markets.

- Legal · AZ
Arizona AG Sues Express Scripts, Optum Over Opioid Role
Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes filed a consumer fraud lawsuit Oct. 1 against pharmacy benefit managers Express Scripts and Optum, alleging their formulary and rebate practices fueled the state's opioid epidemic over more than two decades. The complaint alleges the PBMs gave OxyContin unrestricted preferred formulary status in exchange for confidential payments from Purdue Pharma, avoided prior authorization and step-therapy controls, distributed misleading materials downplaying addiction risk, and sold prescriber data for targeted opioid marketing. Filed under the Arizona Consumer Fraud Act, the suit seeks restitution, civil penalties, injunctive relief, disgorgement and corrective programs. It closely mirrors a similar Arkansas lawsuit filed against the same two PBMs in June 2024, part of a broader wave of state litigation scrutinizing PBM business practices.
- Legal · SC
OIG Finds SC Underreported $108.6M in Medicaid COVID FMAP Collections
HHS OIG found that South Carolina failed to report approximately $108.6 million of the federal share of Medicaid and CHIP collections subject to the temporary increased FMAP authorized during the COVID-19 public health emergency. The finding stems from an audit examining whether the state properly identified and returned collections tied to the enhanced federal match rate. The report affects South Carolina's Medicaid agency, which will likely need to refund the unreported federal share to CMS and correct its reporting processes. The audit underscores broader compliance risk for states that received the temporary FMAP bump and must accurately reconcile collections against the higher match rate.
- Legal · WI
OIG Finds Wisconsin May Have Misclaimed $455M in School Medicaid Funds
The HHS Office of Inspector General reports that Wisconsin may have improperly claimed $455 million in federal Medicaid reimbursement for its school-based services program. The finding affects the state Medicaid agency and school districts that bill Medicaid for services delivered to eligible students, as OIG's audit identifies claims that did not meet federal reimbursement requirements. The report does not specify a comment deadline but signals likely recoupment action and corrective-action requirements from CMS. The audit underscores recurring compliance risk in state school-based Medicaid billing programs nationally.
- Legal
Oracle Health Breach Now Affects 29 Hospital Systems
Becker's Hospital Review reports that 29 hospitals and health systems have confirmed patient data was compromised in a 2025 breach of Oracle Health's legacy Cerner systems, with the intrusion dating back to at least Jan. 22, 2025. Affected organizations include Atrium Health, AdventHealth, Christus Health, Baptist Health South Florida, and LifeBridge Health, among others. Oracle Health reportedly asked healthcare organizations to delay patient notification while the investigation continued, and the vendor now faces legal action over the incident. Health systems are continuing to notify patients as the full scope of affected entities becomes clearer.