Judge Dismisses Tampa General's 340B Lawsuit Against Eli Lilly
A federal judge dismissed Tampa General Hospital's lawsuit against Eli Lilly over its 340B claims data requirement, ruling Nov. 18 that the hospital's state-law claims cannot proceed in court. The judge cited the 2011 Supreme Court decision Astra USA v. Santa Clara County, finding Congress did not give 340B hospitals the right to sue drugmakers directly, and pointed to HHS's administrative dispute process as the proper avenue. The dismissal is without prejudice, and the hospital has 30 days to file an amended complaint. Tampa General had sued July 2 under Florida's consumer protection law after Lilly cut off its 340B pricing June 18 over the hospital's refusal to submit claims-level data, with the hospital reporting it was paying 25% to 50% more on average for Lilly drugs. The order notes similar suits are pending from Dartmouth Health's Mary Hitchcock Memorial Hospital and five Massachusetts hospitals.