HHS Drops Appeal, Leaving Section 1115 DSH Day Vacatur Intact
On November 17, 2026, the Fifth Circuit dismissed the HHS Secretary's appeal in Covenant Medical Center v. Kennedy after the Secretary voluntarily requested dismissal before a briefing schedule was set, according to a Hall Render blog post. The dismissal leaves intact a district court ruling that vacated a 2023 regulation excluding Section 1115 demonstration patient days from the Medicaid fraction numerator used in DSH calculations. The district court had relied on its own earlier Baylor All Saints decision and the Fifth Circuit's 2019 Forrest General Hospital ruling. Hall Render notes the vacatur applies nationwide and advises hospitals, particularly those with a June 30 fiscal year end, to add these days to their Medicaid listing when preparing upcoming cost report submissions.