Consumer Voice Finds Abuse Citations at CMS 'High-Performing' Iowa Nursing Homes
The National Consumer Voice for Quality Long-Term Care analyzed federal data and found that between April 2025 and July 2026, 173 of 1,699 nursing homes nationally ranked "high performing" by CMS were cited at least once for failing to protect residents from abuse and neglect, including 10 facilities in Iowa. All 173 homes qualify for CMS's new abbreviated, risk-based inspection process and display "gold trophy" icons on the Care Compare website. Most citations involved failure to report abuse or neglect incidents to state inspectors, cited at 100 of the 173 facilities; failure to properly investigate abuse was cited at 53 facilities, and underlying abuse or neglect was cited at 42. CMS began using the risk-based inspection process, which replaces more thorough traditional inspections at designated higher-performing, lower-risk homes, on September 8, 2026. Consumer Voice opposes the new system, arguing the high-performing designation does not reflect actual quality of care.