Legal
Latest
- Legal · VA
Virginia Hospital Pays $19.2M to Settle Unnecessary Surgery Fraud Case
Chesapeake Regional Medical Center finalized a deferred prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Virginia on Oct. 23, resolving healthcare fraud charges tied to medically unnecessary procedures performed by former OB-GYN Javaid Perwaiz. The hospital will pay $6.4 million in restitution to healthcare programs including Medicare, Medicaid and Tricare, plus establish a $12.8 million fund for affected patients, who have six months to file claims once the two-year agreement term begins. Court documents show hospital leaders repeatedly renewed Perwaiz's privileges and continued billing despite known concerns about documentation, medical necessity and sterilization consent. The hospital must retain an independent compliance monitor and implement new oversight safeguards; if it complies, prosecutors will dismiss the criminal charges.
- Legal · VA
Judge Dismisses RICO Claims, Most Defendants in UVA Health Suit
A federal judge in the Western District of Virginia dismissed all claims against former UVA Health leaders, including ex-CEO K. Craig Kent, and ruled the University of Virginia is immune from suit as an arm of the state. Four physicians had alleged the leaders pushed fraudulent billing practices to inflate procedure costs and retaliated against them for objecting, including claims under RICO and the False Claims Act. The judge dismissed the RICO claims for a second time, finding the physicians were harmed for refusing to go along with the scheme rather than as direct targets of racketeering. Only two retaliation claims survive, both against UVA Physicians Group under the federal False Claims Act and Virginia Fraud Against Taxpayers Act, which will proceed to discovery; plaintiffs have until Nov. 4 to file a revised complaint limited to those claims.
- Legal
Law Firm Warns Long-Term Care Providers on OBBBA Medicaid Cuts
In a client alert, Bricker Graydon Wyatt LLP argues that long-term care providers face acute financial exposure from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), signed into law in July 2025. The firm contends that OBBBA's changes to Medicaid financing will squeeze payments to nursing facilities and other long-term care providers more severely than other provider types. The alert urges providers to begin preparing now for the law's downstream effects on reimbursement. The piece does not cite a specific effective date but frames the cuts as a looming operational and financial risk.
- Legal
Centene Sues CMS Over 2027 Medicare Advantage Star Ratings
Centene has filed suit against CMS challenging its 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, joining a growing list of insurers contesting how CMS calculated their quality scores. The St. Louis-based insurer argues its ratings should be recalculated, a change that could unlock hundreds of millions of dollars in bonus payments tied to higher star scores. The case adds to mounting litigation pressure on CMS's star ratings methodology from multiple Medicare Advantage carriers.

- Legal
Hospitals Sue Again to Block 340B Rebate Pilot Before Jan. 1
HRSA has approved rebate plans from 10 drugmakers covering 21 drugs under a revised 340B Rebate Model Pilot Program set to start Jan. 1. Under the model, covered entities pay wholesale acquisition cost upfront and must submit claims data within 45 days to receive rebates, rather than receiving discounts at purchase. The AHA, Maine Hospital Association and four hospitals sued in federal court in Maine on Oct. 9, arguing HRSA ignored warnings the pilot could cost hospitals over $1 billion a year, and are seeking a temporary restraining order; a similar prior version was blocked by the same court in December 2025. A bipartisan House bill would delay the pilot through 2028, while drugmakers and PhRMA have moved to intervene to defend the plans, citing billions in alleged duplicate discount payments.
- Legal · VA
Columnist Says GOP Medicaid Cuts Fuel Midterm Backlash
In a Virginian-Pilot opinion column, the writer cites UVA political analyst Larry Sabato's prediction of a Democratic "blue wave" or "tsunami" in the November 3 midterms, driven partly by backlash against Trump administration policies. The author argues that congressional Republicans' approval of Medicaid and food stamp cuts, alongside tariffs, immigration enforcement, and war spending, has alienated voters and damaged the GOP's standing heading into the election. Sabato projects Democrats could win at least 224 House seats and reach a 50-50 Senate split, with Virginia's Kiggans-Luria and Wittman-Taylor races cited as competitive indicators. The piece also discusses Trump's push for mid-decade redistricting and broader concerns about democratic discourse.

- Legal
House Committee Investigates PBMs Over Alleged Retaliatory Pharmacy Audits
The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform launched an investigation Oct. 23 into pharmacy benefit managers Optum Rx, CVS Caremark and Express Scripts, examining whether independent pharmacies were targeted with punitive audits for publicly supporting HR 6610. Chairman James Comer said audit notices increased after a July committee markup of the bill, which would require PBMs serving Federal Employees Health Benefits Program plans to pay pharmacies a capped benchmark price and a dispensing fee tied to state Medicaid rates. The committee cited one audit over a $0.99 medication that consumed hundreds of staff hours at an independent pharmacy. CVS said it will respond to the committee's letter; Optum Rx declined comment and Express Scripts has not yet responded.
- Legal
CMS Updates Stark Law Self-Disclosure Protocol Ahead of November Deadline
In a client alert, Thompson Coburn LLP reports that CMS has updated its Voluntary Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol (SRDP), the mechanism providers and suppliers use to voluntarily disclose actual or potential violations of the federal physician self-referral law (Stark Law). The firm outlines changes providers should understand before a November 1, 2026 compliance date tied to the updated protocol. Hospitals, physician groups, and other providers with existing or suspected Stark Law exposure are directly affected, since the SRDP governs how they report violations and negotiate settlements with CMS. The alert emphasizes reviewing the revised protocol now to ensure any pending or future disclosures comply with the new requirements.
- Legal
Second Trade Group Sues HHS Over ACA Broker Enrollment Freeze
A trade association has filed a second lawsuit against HHS and CMS challenging the agencies' decision to bar new agents and brokers from registering to sell Affordable Care Act marketplace plans during the 2027 open enrollment period. The suit follows an earlier legal challenge over the same policy, arguing the freeze unlawfully restricts broker participation in federal marketplace enrollment activities. The case adds pressure on HHS and CMS as open enrollment approaches, with brokers and agencies awaiting a judicial resolution on whether the freeze can stand.

- Legal
CMS Seeks Input on Fraud Contractors, Gains New Exclusion Power
In a client alert, McDonald Hopkins reports that CMS is reviewing its fraud-investigation contractor structure through a request for information while simultaneously acquiring new authority to exclude providers from federal healthcare programs. The firm advises providers and counsel to evaluate these two developments together rather than separately, since combined they could change how fraud cases are investigated and how exclusion decisions are made. The alert does not specify a comment deadline or effective date for either change. The piece frames this as a compliance planning issue for providers facing potential program integrity scrutiny.
- Legal
Boston Court Hears Challenge as States Prep Work Requirements
A federal judge in Boston heard arguments in a lawsuit challenging new Medicaid work requirements, while state Medicaid directors met separately in Maryland to plan implementation of the same rules. The two events underscore the uncertainty facing states as they build eligibility systems and reporting infrastructure for work requirements even as the legal basis for the policy remains contested. Directors are grappling with operational questions including verification processes, exemptions, and timelines, without clarity on whether litigation could pause or alter the requirements. No ruling was reported from the hearing.
- Legal
OIG Approves Hearing Referral Program Under Anti-Kickback Safe Harbor
The HHS Office of Inspector General issued Advisory Opinion 26-18 on September 9, 2026, approving a proposed arrangement connecting patients with potential hearing loss to participating audiologists, hearing aid specialists and ENT providers. A company whose parent makes ENT medical devices would operate the referral program, charging participating hearing providers a flat annual membership fee unrelated to referral volume or value. OIG found the arrangement implicates the Anti-Kickback Statute but qualifies for the referral services safe harbor because participation is open, fees are cost-based, providers retain clinical independence, and patients receive written disclosures and must consent before referral. OIG did not address the separate arrangement between the requestor and primary care clinicians using the underlying hearing-screening device.
- Legal
Law Firm Explains When Medicaid Audits Trigger Federal Fraud Probes
In a client-advisory piece, law firm Oberheiden P.C. outlines the circumstances under which a routine Medicaid audit escalates into a federal fraud investigation. The firm explains that federal authorities get involved when auditors uncover evidence suggesting intentional billing fraud or other statutory violations, which can expose providers to civil or criminal liability under multiple federal statutes. The piece advises providers facing such allegations to adopt a proactive, strategic defense early to reduce exposure to significant civil or criminal penalties. No specific case, audit, or enforcement action is discussed; the piece is general compliance guidance for providers.
- Legal
HHS, DOJ Launch False Claims Act Self-Disclosure Pilot Program
HHS and the Department of Justice's Civil Division have launched a six-month pilot allowing healthcare companies to self-report potential civil False Claims Act violations in exchange for coordinated settlement terms. Qualifying companies must disclose full details of the conduct, provide supporting documents, describe remedial steps, and repay the government under a 1.25x to 1.6x multiplier based on factors like disclosure speed and leadership involvement. In return, companies receive a DOJ release, and HHS OIG will forgo exclusion or corporate integrity agreements while CMS will not revoke billing or enrollment privileges. Healthcare companies, including Medicaid managed care plans and providers, have until April 22, 2027 to submit disclosures electronically; incomplete or late submissions will not be reviewed.
- Legal · TX
Gilead Pays $45 Million to Settle Texas Medicaid Kickback Claims
Gilead Sciences agreed to pay $45 million to settle allegations brought by the Texas attorney general and a whistleblower that the company paid kickbacks to improperly influence prescriptions billed to Texas Medicaid. The whistleblower lawsuit alleged Gilead paid a third-party company to deploy registered nurses to recommend its drugs and offered free support services to doctors in exchange for prescribing, practices that allegedly led to false claims submitted to government programs. The case traces back to lawsuits filed roughly a decade ago by Health Choice Advocates and related firms against multiple drugmakers over similar nurse-outreach arrangements. Gilead is the latest pharmaceutical company to reach a settlement with Texas over these marketing practices.
- Legal · IA
Iowa Fines Chiropractor $1,000 Over Billing Settlement Disclosure
The Iowa Board of Chiropractic has fined Taylor Vanden Wynboom $1,000 after he failed to timely disclose a civil settlement with the federal government over billing practices at his former Ankeny practice, Nova Integrated Health. The board alleges Wynboom entered a June 2024 settlement, paying $52,000 with no admission of liability, but did not notify the board within the required 30 days as mandated, and separately cited him for unethical conduct. Under the resolution, Wynboom must pay the penalty and complete 30 hours of training on ethics and proper billing and coding. The underlying billing dispute traces to a device called Sanexas and allegations that a billing consultant, the National Billing Institute, helped providers upcode and bill for services not rendered to Medicare and other insurers.

- Legal · CA
DOJ Charges 15 in $2B Healthcare Fraud Schemes, Including Medi-Cal Case
The Justice Department, through the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Central District of California, charged 15 defendants, including six medical professionals, in multiple alleged healthcare fraud schemes totaling about $2 billion in fraudulent claims. The largest scheme, described as the largest substance abuse treatment fraud case ever prosecuted by DOJ, allegedly generated $1.6 billion by recruiting vulnerable patients with high-reimbursing insurance and cycling them through unnecessary treatment. Other cases involve unnecessary vascular procedures, hospice fraud, genetic testing kickbacks, and a nearly $270 million Medi-Cal pharmacy scheme that allegedly exploited a temporary suspension of prior authorization requirements, with Medi-Cal paying out about $179 million of the allegedly fraudulent claims. Eight defendants were arrested October 22, and all defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
- Legal · KY
OIG Finds Kentucky Lapses in Overseeing Child Treatment Programs
An HHS Office of Inspector General report finds that Kentucky could do more to protect children placed in Qualified Residential Treatment Programs (QRTPs), facilities that serve youth with significant behavioral or mental health needs who are removed from family settings. The report identifies gaps in the state's oversight and safety protections for children residing in these programs. Findings point to specific compliance shortfalls the state Medicaid and child welfare agencies will need to address. The report does not specify an implementation deadline but calls for corrective action by Kentucky.
- Legal · CA
Nurse Anesthetists Sue California Over Hospital Staffing Rules
The California Association of Nurse Anesthesiology filed suit October 1 in San Francisco County Superior Court against the California Department of Public Health and the Office of Administrative Law. The complaint alleges state regulations improperly bar certified registered nurse anesthetists from hospital medical staff, conflicting with state law that allows licensed practitioners deemed competent to serve. CANA seeks to strike down the rules, citing 2024 enforcement actions at two Modesto hospitals that removed CRNAs from medical staff and led to cancellation of nearly 1,000 surgical procedures. CDPH denied petitions to revise the regulations from CANA and the American Nurses Association\California in September 2025, prompting this litigation.
- Legal · WV
Commentary: WV Rural Health Funds Can't Offset Medicaid Cuts
In a commentary piece, the author argues that West Virginia's nearly $200 million in federal rural health transformation funding for 2026 cannot substitute for the state's projected loss of more than $5.3 billion in Medicaid funding over the next decade. The author contends that while the new program can support telehealth, workforce recruitment and technology, it cannot replace health coverage itself, and that West Virginia's rural hospitals, already operating on thin margins, face heightened closure risk as Medicaid revenue declines. The piece also highlights new work requirements beginning January 1, 2027 for Medicaid expansion adults ages 19-64, warning that administrative burdens similar to those seen during Medicaid unwinding will cause further coverage losses. The author frames these cuts as a direct threat to hospital stability, uncompensated care burdens and patient medical debt.
